Menu toggle

Cayman 718 GPF Failure

Agree, a very sucint summary and clearly states the state of play.

This is beyond David and Golieth, a 'small' group of people lumbered with a duff system verses the Corporate fortress that is Porsche.

The dealers are helpless, just puppets, Porsche's first moat of defense.

Finding a alternative solution to resetting (as it seems now to be developing) is to me a perfect answer to these car's issue.

Nothing to do with Porsche, they are on another planet and do business by other values. Enthusiasts will have taken note.
The Dealers can't use the 'other' system coming along, so they lock themselves out, and the Independents can enjoy a solution and keep the customer to themselves.

A focus on the alternative system gets these cars sorted, Porsche do not win, they have no interest, this I feel is not on thier radar at all.

It is tempting to say the Club has let the side down, but they have allowed this thread to run and run, well done for this.

Dave's extraordinary work and determination wins the day!
 
Morning Guys & Girls

A guy contacted me on Wednesday from Malaysia with our P242F ash DTC.

His garage checked over the vehicle and as usual found the 100% fault code, they gave him a few repair options.

1. Clean the GPF filter and carry out a regeneration.

2. Change the particulate filter

3. Disable the exhaust particulate filter system.

Ive sent him lots of information regarding what to look for, so his garage have all the information they need on this fault.

He contacted me this morning to say they are carrying out option 1, including a regeneration, which is what our Porsche memo recommends.

I have asked for the post regeneration data to see if the reset was successful.

We have another vehicle thats going to have its ash adaptation carried out, but it may go into next week due to to work commitments.

Will keep you informed of progress, enclose the data information sent from my Malaysian owner.

Regards
Dave
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20261020_183449_WhatsApp.jpg
    Screenshot_20261020_183449_WhatsApp.jpg
    1 MB · Views: 7
Hi Dave

Back in September, John said he wanted to follow up the article published in Porsche Post and produce an update in print. He said he was going to meet up with you and prepare something for PP. Did anything happen with this?
Regards
Mark
 
Hi Mark,

Nothing booked at the moment, but hopefully we will catch-up, we have lots more information now than we did on the last Porsche Post article, which unfortunately doesn't look good for Porsche and their Dealers.

We have more of our cars out there with new modified filters fitted with software ash levels that are worse than the original ash accumulation on the original GPF filter, bearing in mind the mileage covered, and the time on the car.

So yes, it will be brilliant to get together with John and update you all.

Hopefully we can meet up on the 13th of November at the Classic Car show at the NEC.

Dave
 
Hi Dave

Great to see that all your hard work and perseverance is helping people while also building a useful pool of data.
I've included an update on my GPF journey below. The OPC currently has an open technical ticket regarding the differential pressure sensor, which was recently replaced. Despite the replacement, it is still showing a reading of -1.24 hPa with the ignition on and engine off, which would appear abnormal.
Interestingly, following replacement of the differential pressure sensor, the reported ash loading has reduced to 2.75%, It will be interesting to see what feedback comes back from the technical investigation on the sensor .
1793018948215.png
 
Hi Tony,

Thanks for providing this information, its brilliant detail.

To start with, you have never had a minus differential pressure sensor reading on your car from new, they have all been positive.

Your spreadsheet confirms this in great detail.

The reason why the new differential pressure sensor is reading a negative percentage with the ignition on, engine not running, is due to an offset calibration error in the DME software.

A new sensor should definitely read a 0.00 hPa value ignition on, engine not running, and a very small positive reading with engine running.

Why this is happening is very simple, the old sensor data in the DME is conflicting with the new sensor reading, and the old ash % data still in the DME.

On our cars the function to adapt a newly fitted differential pressure sensor is not on our cars, just like the Ash % adaptation is not available either.

So the old software data readings are still a problem, because they can't be reset correctly back to zero, which would in turn re set the algorithm.

The issue you have reported on your car says it all,

Basically the algorithm that calculates the ash and soot percentages can not function correctly as it was designed to do.

Every time we have carried out our own adaptation of the ash % value using a different diagnostic scanner, the soot values in both the calculated and measured values instantly appear at very high percentages.

High enough to put the ( Regenerate particle filter) warning message on the dashboard, along with the DTC code P2463 (Particulate filter soot load high).

We then have to drive the car carrying out the deacceleration style, and we always have to drive the car quite a lot of miles to lower the soot values.
So the warning light goes out and we can clear the code easil.

It seems this rising Ash % measured value seems to be masking the soot level information in the software, even though our cars never fill up with soot.

These GPF filters seem to deal with the soot loading through passive regeneration very well through a rise in the exhaust temperature on spirited runs.

This is confirmed, because we never see a soot regeneration message on our dashboards even when these GPF filters are supposedly blocked 100% with Ash.

Dave








 
Hi Guys & Girls,

Just heard from our 718 owner in Kuala Lumpur in Malaysia.

His garage cleaned his filter and carried out a regeneration.

He sent us this information, one photo showing the 0.00% measured ash reading after this work was completed.

And the second photo showing the measured ash reading was now at 61.57% after 120 miles.

This shows you how ridiculous this software issue is.

The ash hits 100% and puts the light on, a clean and regeneration changes the software to 0.00% for a short while, then it comes back.

The crazy thing is our Dealers and Porsche believe that this Ash is real, so much so they replace the GPF, without doing a back pressure check.

Its like magic, here one minute, and gone the next.

This is a perfect example of why we are campaigning to stop this stupidity.

Enclose both photos to support this post

Dave
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot_20261028_193157_WhatsApp.jpg
    Screenshot_20261028_193157_WhatsApp.jpg
    932.2 KB · Views: 5
  • Screenshot_20261028_193212_WhatsApp.jpg
    Screenshot_20261028_193212_WhatsApp.jpg
    665.8 KB · Views: 5
Morning Guys & Girls

I would like to share with you this spooky information regarding the software ash % coming back on two of our cars.

The car above had 61.57% of ash coming back after a road test of 120 miles, after the filter was cleaned, and a regeneration was carried out.

In April this year we had a Boxster 2.0 2019 car that had a new modified filter replaced free of charge by Porsche.
When the owner picked up the car they asked to see the GPF % ash level.

The ash level was at 62.75%, and the car had covered 100 miles of road testing.

They couldn't believe what they were seeing, they have agreed to take the car back for another Ash% check.

I have on file the GPF report from the Dealer to this owner to support this statement.

So whats the difference between these two cars.

The difference is, the second car had a very expensive GPF filter replaced by a Porsche Dealer, who contacted Porsche Technical, for authorisation, probably followed the internal memo instructions, and definitely did not carry out an exhaust back pressure test.

Thank goodness we helped the owner to persuade Porsche to pay for its replacement.

Spooky returning Ash percentages, and road testing mileages.

Dave
 
Hi Guys & Girls
Sorry its been a while since we last posted.

Its always bothered me that our Dealers will not carry out a simple backpressure check to confirm these GPF filters are definitely blocked with Ash.

And also this simple check was never included in the Porsche internal memo dated 3rd March 2025. The memo provided a comprehensive list of checks to be carried out, covering the Ash P242F (ash load to high) fault on these cars.

So after a bit of research we found this information that may help us going forward.

Under part 4, Chapter 1 of the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 ( in force since April 2025). Garages have a strict legal duty of professional diligence and cannot sell unnecessary repairs or even withhold key facts about known software behaviour.

A Dealer cannot use the excuse that the Manufacturer will not allow them to do this test.

The high potential cost of this repair deserves the correct diagnosis being carried out, and the fact that its part of the emmision control on these cars, it definitely needs to be done correctly.

Condemning these GPF filters, without measuring actual physical backpressure, falls very short of standard industry diagnostic practice.

So going forward if we are contacted by any more owners with this fault on their cars that have been refused this simple back pressure check. We will help them
with a formal complaint under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 and the DMCC Act 2024.

Afterall these Dealership's have statutory obligations under the UK consumer law, and why wouldn't they want to carry out this extra check.

We are still testing our two cars that have had the ASH adaptation carried out, and the ash % readings are still at 0.00%.

Hopefully a third car will be done over the next month, so we can have more evidence that our software Ash adaptation as been accepted on these cars.

We went to the NEC Classic car show on Friday, and called in at the Porsche Club stand. I managed to speak to Steve Johnson, but unfortunatly he was very busy and we didnt have chance to bring him up to date with our ash adaptation testing and results.

Hopefully we can get all this information put in an article in the Porsche Post magazine which would make interesting reading for all our members.


Regards
Dave
 
Hi Dave

You have said all along that this issue has been mis-diagnosed and this would fall under your observations above.

You mention about putting an up to date article in the Porsche Post, you talked about you and John (Dickinson) getting together, this was some time ago now, how is it coming along?

I think it would make interesting reading, not just for Cayman and Boxster owners that have been affected but anyone who has a GPF fitted.

Regards

Mark
 
Hi Mark,

Yes hopefully soon we will get together and draft out a post that will cover all our investigations and the data we have collected along the way.

And more importantly the adaptation work we have done to try and fix this software issue, that the Porsche PWIS diagnostic tester can not do.

When you really get down to this fault, all it ever needed was a way to re set the ash % when its proved beyond any doubt that the ash is not real, and the differential pressure sensor is telling the truth.

Just like our diesel cars, when the DPF is full of soot, you check the soot loading and sensor reading. If its to high, you clean out the soot re check the readings if all is ok.

You then carry out a regeneration, or if need be, carry out the DPF adaptation, usually by telling the ECU that the DPF has been replaced.

Unfortunately we can not do this either has a reset, or when these modified GPF filters are replaced.

Has we have said before, how can real ash be present one minute and be gone the next after a soot regeneration.

And regarding the soot, we never see any when the ash % software gets to 100% and the code P242F is present.

One thing we do know for certain is that when you do an ash % adaptation the soot instantly comes back, sometimes as high as 80%. And it always puts on the soot warning light and message with the DTC P2463 ( Particulate filter-soot load high).

If you cannot do extended road tests to get the soot levels down, the Regenerate Particle Filter message comes up on the dashboard with code 26740 (Particulate filter -Regeneration needed).

But if you carry on driving the message will go off, has both the soot measured, and calculated levels get back to zero.

Funny software, no soot when the ash % is high, and when the ash % is low, high soot values, which we never normally see ever.

Could it be that the software % ash messured software calculation is hiding the soot loading calculations.

This could explain why we never see any soot regeneration messages on our dashboards.

But again the differential pressure sensor is not giving any high readings on either the soot or ash values when these fault codes are present.

Software can be a pain

Dave
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top