As someone who has been part of this from the beginning, working with Dave and also getting the original article in Porsche Post, I guess I should put a Cayman Register and PCGB perspective on this, albeit that it is my personal opinion and not 'sanctioned' by the Club.
This all started over two years ago with a CEL light coming on and the dealers were trying to charge £7-9k to turn it off. So what has been achieved through Dave's work?
- there is now no reason any owner should accept this diagnosis and we can help them work through this. Dave has saved members £thousands.
- the GPF fault is the result of a problem elsewhere, probably in the software algorithms. GPF's don't 'block' themselves.
- there is enough publicity on here and the related forums like Piston Heads to think that anyone who still hands over their hard earned cash for a new GPF is daft!
- we will move through this stage as dealers realise they will be rebuffed.
- if anyone is willing to be identified on here, asking for help because they have received such a diagnosis there is no problem with naming the OPC providing that it is restricted to being factual, supportable and 'unemotional'.
Summary: there are a relatively small number of cars out there that may throw up a P242F error code. We know that the OPC diagnosis is incorrect and can help owners push back against a costly GPF replacement. That is a significant win in my book.
But, of course, it would be good to get to the bottom of this and have Porsche confirm what is really going on. Just so we know!
We know that the GPF, AOS and other components have been upgraded during the period from 2019. We also have a body of evidence to support the fact that these are not the problem in terms of the ash load:
- replacing these components may be a reprieve but in some cases, such as Paul's, the dealers do this and still can't complete a fix. We also believe that the problem will recur in other cars that have been ‘fixed’.
- the fact that Porsche are still issuing different instructions suggests that they do not feel they have a complete solution to offer. My understanding is that the document was a letter, not a technical bulletin, again pointing to uncertainty at Porsche.
- we do not know why this affects some, but not all, cars in this 2019 period of production.
Dave has pointed at the software and the related hardware (sensors etc.) as being at the root of the problem almost from the start. This is based on:
- the VAL reports producing unbelievable results
- the inability of the dealers to reset the software after replacing the hardware.
- and finally Paul's experience where, having stripped the engine, replacing virtually everything that can be replaced, they are now pulling the car back to the centre and doing a deal.
Porsche GB are stonewalling us over this, and doing it successfully. They simply do not respond to the club, their customers or even the OPC's. It is a numbers game. Porsche has no reason or incentive to do anything other than deal with this matter on a case by case basis. Being generous we might find 30 owners willing to share their stories in public. We might get more by 'advertising' for owners to step up. But most won't want the hassle, just a working car. A decent OPC sells over 30 cars a month. These Caymans would be 0.01% of Porsche production in 2025. (The VW emissions case affected 11 million vehicles.) In Porsche terms this GPF issue is a minor blip. They have dealt with much bigger issues in the past - PDF gearboxes where owners had to buy new ones instead of getting the fault repaired (Still the case today) - wheels falling off centre lock cars (they could not ignore that one) - the myriad issues affecting the electric vehicles - 997 engines grenading on cars that had barely covered 50,000 miles. The list goes on. Unpalatable as it might be, in our world this 'GPF' is a big deal. In Porsche world it is in the inbox of a junior technician. The same applies to trying to attract the attention of the media. It only affected a certain series of cars produced in 2019. It is yesterday's headline in a world where Caymans and Boxsters continue to be rated as highly reliable.
It is at this point that I start speculating, based on the fact that I cannot believe that Porsche do not know where the problem lies. Such ignorance is inconceivable. So, consider the hypothesis that they know the answer, that there is a fault in the calibration of sensors and, or, the programming of the ECU etc. and the controlling of emissions. This fault is enough to trigger the P242F error code in some circumstances. All these systems are subject to TUV and global certifications and any changes would require re-certification and potentially cost $lots and $lots. Better to keep the lid on it, acknowledge nothing and let OPC's handle the relatively small number of cases, most of which can be dealt with somehow.
So, where does that leave us?
1. we do have knowledge and leverage to help those who are affected by the P242F error code.
2. we do not have leverage to make Porsche explain the issue and offer a solution through a technical bulletin.
From a register and club perspective I will take 1 above as having done our job for members. I am not happy about 2 but I think we have to live with it unless we can see a negative impact on those members that we can get hold of.
Therefore, we keep going, support our members, publicise as much as possible on here and elsewhere and see what, if anything, developes.