Menu toggle

Life after Cayman - My 2021 Alpine A110 Legende GT.

I'm currently waiting for a good weather window to take the Alpine A110 north and west on the A832 Achnasheen to Gairloch route via Loch Maree. This is a route I have driven countless times in all of my previous Caymans. It will provide a meaningful comparative test drive.

Meantime, photos of a delightful walk at Chatsworth House last week.

Brian



 
At last the weather is behaving. I plan to take the A110 Legende GT on a day trip to Loch Maree for a final appraisal. The report on my Final Verdict will follow shortly afterwards.

Meantime, a preview of the road I shall be driving on. Loch Maree is the loch seen in the background of this photo. This is the sort of road that should suit the agility of the A110 ideally. A complete contrast to the M6 and Manchester ring road.

Brian



 
I enjoyed a superb drive today in the A110 via the A835 - A832 to Talladale by Loch Maree. This was my first opportunity for a drive on one of my favourite Highland routes with the car now fully run-in. It was pure joy.

A few photos to follow before I post The Final Verdict on the A110 Legende GT in comparison to my 12 years of Cayman ownership experiences.

Brian

Note the low, hazy, winter sun. This photo was taken at mid-day.

 
Brian, I have been reading with great interest and enjoyment your observations and stories on all the cars that you have owned, and it is particularly interesting to here of your Alpine experience. I'm sorry that I did not get to meet you at Oulton Park this year, I had been looking forward to going there. Your account of driving in Manchester highlights again how all built in sat nav devices are hopelessly inferior to the sat nav that is available through a mobile phone these days. In my experience by far the best for safely and accuracy guiding you thorough a unfamiliar complex city is TomTom, their routing, interface and traffic avoidance is second to none. Speed camera warning also excellent. Maps are downloaded to your device so no mobile data service is required. You have to pay a small fee of 12.99 a year and it is worth every single penny. Waze is free but it's routes are sometimes strange. Its as good as TomTom for Speed cameras though. Unsurprisingly Google Maps has the best search functions and has the fantastically useful ability to make it guide you on the roads that you choose to drive by being able to create a custom route. All of these can be used in current Porsche cars using Apple Car Play; I assume that the Alpine also has Car Play? If not, I would much rather just mount the phone on a windscreen mount than use the awful built in navigation.

I was interested to see that you met up with BrianJ; I too had the enormous pleasure of meeting him and his wife when they came to the Region 7 MOTY (Midweek Of The Year) which I had organised in the Scottish Border region in October.

I await with some eagerness the next instalment.

 
Graham,

The A110 sat nav is not nearly as good as the latest version of PCM previously experienced on my Macan Turbo. I navigated successfully both in Europe and the UK with the Porsche PCM sat nav and found the very latest Google Maps satellite view excellent. When I reported my difficulties with programming the Alpine sat nav to the sales contact at Manchester Alpine Centre, his frank reply admitted that the A110 system fell somewhat short of expectations compared to current Porsche PCM sat nav. I'm also finding Apple Car Play problematic on the A110, resulting in using the plug-in lead to connect my iPhone as an iPod device. It's all too much of a faff when you are about to set out on a trip. I'm still working my way through through the tutorials.

The A110 driving experience is thankfully far more rewarding than the infotainment. More details to be revealed later.

Brian

 
Having made my decision on the final score regarding the 2021 Alpine A110 Legende GT compared to my Cayman ownership experiences, the problem of presentation then reared its formidable head. How to present the result in a clear and succinct manner became an overriding concern. Already, car magazine scribes and You Tube podcasters have posted countless articles and videos of the Alpine A110 in all is configurations, comparing it to numerous sports coupe contemporaries. I would be boring the socks off of readers if I were to simply reiterate what has already been written at great length by those more competent than I at car journalism.

Instead, I have decided to use the well tried and tested method of announcing the result in reverse order as is the standard practice with magazine Car of the Year articles.

So, what I propose to do is write a short piece on each car comprising the top three, explaining my reasons in each case.

Having owned five Caymans it will come as no surprise that this car will dominate the results. It’s five against one after all. What I shall try to do as honestly as I can is describe where my edition of the Alpine A110 lies in comparison to a very strong group of high quality contenders.

My next post will begin with my decision of the top three in reverse order. I hope readers will enjoy reading my final results, taken in the spirit of my own personal experiences.

Brian

 
Joint 2nd Place

2012 987.2 Porsche Cayman R 6-Speed Manual.

Much has already been written regarding this car’s superlative handling balance, having earned its place as an iconic Cayman sought after by collectors and driving enthusiasts alike. The CR is best when specced with the 6-speed manual gearbox and carbon bucket seats as specced on my car. Being a OPC Edinburgh ex-demo model, I had no hand in the specification of this car. The colour, Meteor Grey Metallic, was uncommon for the CR with most others being White, Black, or Peridot Green. With aluminium 997 GT3 doors, mechanical LSD, 19” lightweight alloy wheels, reduced sound insulation, and Alcantara interior trim, this car looked the business from the get-go. My car had the smaller 54 litre petrol tank which came as standard, with the larger 64 litre tank being a no-cost option. I recall complaining about this small tank choice to the sales team at Edinburgh, thinking it would compromise my touring plans. As it turned out, the small tank proved a real blessing. I’ll return to that aspect later.

My first two years with the CR was spent touring the UK as is my usual practice. In this regard it proved a comfortable and practical, driver’s car ideally suited to the winding A and B roads in my local Highland location. Even though the CR lacked door pockets, I never had any problems storing the usual touring bits and bobs on my journeys throughout the UK. The carbon bucket seats had folding backs where items could be stored behind the seats, and the central arm rest cubby hole, together with the passengers glove compartment, provided all the storage space I needed.

Since retiring from competitive motorsport in 1987 the realisation dawned that the CR was showing such potential that it prompted me to consider a serious return to motorsport competitions. My forte was in Sprints and Hill Climbs, and the CR with its inherent agility and decent power to weight ratio, seemed ideally suited to this category of motorsport. Having been away from competitive driving for 27 years, it was absolutely paramount that I receive the best sport driving tuition available before embarking upon motorsport activities with such a valuable car. To this end, I embarked upon a series of Precision Driving Courses at PEC with the purpose of reawakening and augmenting my existing motorsport driving skills. When enrolling on the three PEC courses, all of which included track time on the Silverstone GP circuit, I made the specific request that I be allocated a tutor with previous competitive motorsport experience.

This proved to be the correct decision, as I was privileged to have full day tutored sessions with Barry Horne, former Carrera Cup GB Champion, Jeremy Palmer, and Ben McLaughlin, both of whom were former champions in motorsport. To supplement the PEC courses I also enlisted several private one-to-one tutored driving sessions at Knockhill circuit with Carrera Cup GB, and current BTCC driver Rory Butcher. As well as using my own CR, the tutored driving sessions also included the PEC Cayman R manual, 997 GT3, 997 GT3RS, and the fabulous 997 GT3RS 4.0. I was pleased to “graduate” from all PEC courses with written reports on my willingness to listen and learn, and my application of the tutor’s instructions when driving such powerful cars at high speed in a variety of track conditions. I now considered myself ready to embark on competing against other competent drivers in my own road registered CR.

If the CR had a weakness it was in the braking department. The iron discs were small diameter and overheated easily at track racing speeds. The result was a soft pedal going too far to the floor to successfully conduct heel-and-toe gear changes at racing speeds. I consequently replaced the brake master cylinder with a 997 GT3 item, and fitted Aeroquip steel braided brake hoses. This modification together with competition brake pads transformed the braking performance more in keeping with a motorsport car. A K&N cotton air filter element and a selection of trial and error wheel spacers completed the modifications. Various tyres were tried and tested. I had already purchased a second set of 19” lightweight alloy wheels for track use. Dunlop Sport Maxx Race, Michelin Cup 2, and Toyo R888 tyres were all tried. Of these, the Toyos offered the best performance for track use, with the Cup 2’s a close second. The less said about the Dunlops the better, other than they were scarily inconsistent in wet track conditions. I soon sold them on to another competitor who came to the same conclusion.

The Cayman R thus mildly modified, was absolutely superb on the track. Having the standard suspension set-up I was confined to adjusting the geometry settings within the factory limitations. The only shortcoming that remained was the comparatively supple OE engine and transaxle mountings. When doing blitz standing starts as was required at hill climb events, the transaxle was prone to tramping. This could be mitigated by modulating revs on the throttle, but it remained a problem at hill climbs, particularly with the sticky Toyo tyres. Anyone considering this type of motorsport competition with a CR would be well advised to fit a more robust engine and transaxle mount. Returning to the topic of the small fuel tank fitted to my CR, this proved an unexpected blessing as I could carry minimum fuel for timed runs without experiencing fuel surging problems. Lightness is everything in hill climbing and sprinting events.

In conclusion, the CR is one of the best buys a keen driver can make in the current Porsche market. A good car with the right spec will cost up to £50,000. If any readers are tempted to look at a CR, please do not be put off by any sensible modifications. The CR is a car that is improved by modding the brakes, exhaust, and induction systems. It is one of the best value driver’s cars available today and fully deserves its joint second place in my opinion.

Brian

A few photos of my much missed Cayman R to follow.

 
My CR in track spec at the 2014 Super Lap Scotland Championship at Knockhill. The sponsors stickers were a compulsory requirement for all competitors.

 
An excellent account and engaging read, thank you Brian.

I too look forward to the next instalment.

 
These are exactly the type of interesting articles that should be appearing in PP.

Keep up the great work.

Paul.

 
An enjoyable read Brian. I was surprised to read that your CR with it’s mechanical LSD suffered axle tramp on hillclimb starts, sounds like it behaved just like my CS without an LSD and particularly if I used launch control - I’d imagined my launch control would have been tramp-less if I had an LSD, your experience suggests not.

 
mr pg said:
Only time I've experienced axle tramp was in my first car. A Morris Minor. :)

My first car was a Morris Minor too, a 1956 803cc model, it taught me what brake fade is 🙂.

Apologies Brian for sending your thread off on a tangent but your experiences are a catalyst for many of our recollections.

 
mr pg said:
Only time I've experienced axle tramp was in my first car. A Morris Minor. :)

Blitz standing starts in a Morris Minor eh? Now there goes an ambitious man!

I soon discovered that racing standing starts with the CR were a fine art, particularly with sticky Toyo tyres properly warmed up. Track surface conditions were also a big factor. After much trial and error, I found engaging the clutch sharply at 4250-4500rpm best. With these revs the CR engine was on cam and clear of the emissions flat spot below 4000rpm. Higher revs caused wasteful wheel-spin, but good for pre-start tyre warming. Anything below 4000rpm caused the engine to bog down, then when the cams came in, transmission tramp ensued. The LSD locked up perfectly at the optimum standing start revs, with a slight left side slide bias on take off. Observers confirmed two tramline rubber marks for several metres after the blitz take-off.

Happy Days!

Brian

Next instalment imminent.







 
Used to get axle tramp in my mother's 1200cc Cortina Mk 1, but strangely never when she was in it.....

 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top