Menu toggle

More chassis issues! 987.2, 2.9/2009 92 K miles

911hillclimber

PCGB Member
Member
Having replaced the 2 rear wheel bearings the car straight after ran 100% right. This was about 4 weeks ago.



Few weeks later took a sudden break to visit Exeter in the car.

Running a deam down the motorway from the West Mids to Exeter, pulled into a services for a pit stop.

Left the services, all good then very suddenly the car rolled about alarmingly, a lateral side to side movement at about 60 mph down the slip road to the motorway. I was convinced it was a puncture.

It passed after about 5 seconds, smoothed out and 1/2 mile later did it again at 70 but not so alarmingly. After a few seconds, all smooth and steering etc all felt normal. Through the 3 days down there it did the same at random times at 30 or 40 or other speeds as if the road surface was uneven.

Each time the sensation was side to side, NO knocks or noises at all (normal for this car).

On the run home all was ok..but a few times a slight wobble, smooth surface.

Left the car parked as usual at home and yesterday (10 days later) went for a local run on roads I know really well.

Had a lot of these 'sideway wobbles' but not as pronounced as the first one coming out of the sevices. The car has never done this before, ever, only just a few weeks after the bearings were done by a Porsche specialist who I trust.

Checked the tyre pressures this afternoon, cold and all are correct if a few pounds low (32 rear, 31 front).

Going over local rough roads may or may not cause a brief wobble feeling, it all is random.

Front tyres are good though 10 years old, rears are good and 3 years old.

Any thoughts please?

I'm taking the rear wheels off tomorrow to look at all the bolts etc.
 
Rear side to side sounds like play in the hub(s), though unusual to be intermittent.

Thinking if not obvious when you remove the rear wheels, try a visit to MOT tester with shaker plates and shake the rear axle.
 
Yes, my original thought also was loose wheels nuts, but can’t see how that would lead to an intermittent problem. Obviously something’s let-go rather suddenly!:oops:

As you say; for starters, best to run a spanner over all the nuts and bolts removed during the bearing replacements to check their security, and also check for play in the bushes just to ensure that nothing’s happened when they’ve been disturbed. Have a good look at the tyres for any untoward run-out when the rear is jacked-up too.

Here’s a link you might find useful:


Jeff
 
Always worth checking wheel bolts.
I only say this had similar issue on a car not a Porsche years ago shortly after new tyres fitted.
There air gun was shot not fully tightened bolts.
Good idea to check springs drop links shocks are fully attached
Good luck with a fix.
Ps might be worth dropping Steve Winter at Jaz a line get his take on it.
 
Yes, Steve Winter contact is a good idea, will do that after this unspectacular up-date.
While I'm drying out thought i would say what I've done this very wet morning.

Jacked the rear up and on stands.
All the wheel nuts were certainly tight, right to about 96 lbft
Spaner checked all the suspension bolts that Zuffenhaus had disturbed in doing the wheel bearings. Odd sizes (18mm!) but all rock solid on both sides.
Bushes look dirty and no cracks, a good pry-bar on all joints showed no movement of ball joints etc, all looks very solid.
New drop links had to be fitted when the bearings were done, so they are tight but removed one lower bolt to see if the anti roll bar might have cracked/broken, but all good.
Sprayed the brake hard lines with lithium grease as a winter prevention, they are in great condition surprisingly. Something MUST be good on this car...

Checked the rear tyres, 3 years old, all good visually, placed back on the car and span both with a pointer close to the rim and tyre wall, all very very even, no eccentricity etc.
Wheel bolts tightened to 96 lbft, but left the pressures as they were, about 1 to 2 lb down but same across the axle.

So, found nothing!

Decided to get wetter and take the fronts off and check things there.
Really as above, lithium greased the coolant hose ends against salt water attak, brake pipes too.

When the rear was done at Zuffenhaus, they ran ther customary safety check.
They reported some tyre wear on the NS front tyre inner edge and some corrosion on the disc inner faces, a warning shot for March's MoT I think.

The car is due a full set of tyres, preferably in the spring and after the chassis is alignment checked/adjusted.

All done and a test drive on local roads.

Still the same condidion (not surprised). 15 mile test drive and on one short downhill stretch where the road surface is rough (not pot-holed) the car wobbled quite a lot. Turned round and re-run the same stretch and the car was arrow straight! Same speed, same road.

So, what next.? Steve Winter, then I think take the car for an alignment check/ tweak, maybe locally or back to Zuffenhaus.

This car just keeps on giving.
 
Well, the fronts are 10 years old and about 7/8th down now, and the rears are 3 years but a good 1/2 way worn. Time for a change of all 4.
The sensation is akin to a very prononced 'tramlining' , random, little to do with rutted surface but I feel very sensitive to undulation.

Potholes etc do not start it.
No noises, no vibrations, nothing through the steering wheel etc just in a A or B road you might get it 3 times, and can be disconcerting as it happens instantly.

Steve Winter next.
 
Its a mystery.

Thinking:

- Wobble occurred when going downhill and not uphill so may be linked to weight shifting forward and repeat downhill & uphill legs to see if it re-occurs.

- Check the inside sidewalls of the tyres for distortion / bulges forming, especially the front given the age.
 
At the moment I'm at a loss as to a solution to this sudden problem. I've sent the problem to Steve Winter by email, he might shed some light on it.
Power on, power off, uphill/downhill all make to difference. Found a stretch of road locally and it wobbled going down hill. Went back and repeated the run and it was OK!

Will ocure at 30 and 60 mph of any speed really.
Checked all 4 wheels this morning off the car, all good, all true, no damage BUT NSF tyre inside edge wearing more than OSF, hence thinking alignment needed and that might be the culprit.
 
Sounds like tyres to me.
Wifes got a Fiat 500 for bobbing around every time we changed lanes on dual carriageway or motorway it tramlined felt like it was in a rut a slight wobble changed the 6 year old rear tyres with tread left i might add but felt hard .
Problem solved
 
A mystery indeed Graham!

Definitely sounds as though everything obvious checks-out okay, so perhaps an earlier than planned tyre refresh and geometry check wouldn’t go amiss at this point.

Jeff
 
I get all the mysteries with this car!
I recon nobody else has probs with thier old Boxsters...

Alignment and tyes in that order I think Jeff, I'm hoping my wife is on this page too.
I'll wait to see what Steve Winter has to say, he replied really quickly last time.

Still cannot work out why this would happen so instantly after the services stop 10 days ago, just out of the blue and about 8 weeks after the bearing change.
It was driving really well until this epidode started.

Going to reset the tyre pressures now the wheels are cold after the run this morning, and see if that changes anything.

Will use Zuffenhaus to check alignment, not sure I trust the local tye shop to do it.

My one thought was/is if the rear lower arm was bolted up tight after the car was back on it's wheels after the bearing fix allowing the bush to be relaxed in it's working position, but doubt Zuffenhaus would not do that. Maybe that could affect the geo enough to be a problem.
 
Last edited:
Have you checked for a broken spring? Breaks are typically near one end and not easily visible. Because only a minimal amount of spring length is lost, static ride height may not be visibly off. Lost piece also means spring may rotate in the seat when moving unloaded. Not sure this would give your symptoms, but worth a check.
 
Just booked the car into Zuffenhaus for a full check on the 30th Nov.
Couldn't bring myself to have the alignment checked etc locally in a large tyre place (that sold me the 3 year old tyres as new...)
Zuff' had no immediate amswer to this problem, but listened hard to my ramblings.
Time will tell.
 
Reply from Warren at Steve Winter's place. Quick response!
He thinks alignment but to change the tyres to new BEFORE alignment so chassis is dialed-in to the new not the old tyres.

Going to follow this as it make perfect sense to me, i should have thought about that myself...

Mich 4S £832 the set of 4.
Not bothering with N spec as I think the 4S is not available now in N spec.
Local shop might have them in stock(!)
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top