Menu toggle

One more Poll

Suffolk944

Moderator
Ok - subsequent to my last poll thread I now have the money burning a hole in my bank account ready and poised for the the next phase of mods to my car (ie mainly a new turbo) BUT I just have a niggling feeling that I could use the money to buy another car. Now of course ending up with a third car is just as daft as blowing the money on more power (some might say) and yet....

So a final poll - should I go with the mods or go with another car (options provided for a few machines I might then consider). Just for fun once more as they say [;)]
 
Voted for the Jag. I have a soft spot for Jags, but I suspect that getting more power in your 944 turbo will only temporarily satisfy your hunger for more, so there is logic in spending the money on something else to distract you from the boost addiction. I nice Jag to cruise around in will be jut the ticket I think - a nice relaxing drive instead.
 
ORIGINAL: sawood12

something else to distract you from the boost addiction.

Would need to be pretty special to be more than a passing distraction.

Maybe a good S2? (before Oli notices this post) [:D]
 
Got me a 735i V8 Cosmos Black sand beige leather with 12 way electric sport seats, lovely condition................pure joy.
Cost a fortune new and i got it for less than the price of a fancy telly.
 
If you can find one, S2 with a manual gearbox. At the time when I got our 968 there was a really fantastic looking condition one that had been up for sale for ages and I went and bought the 968 instead thinking it would be cheaper to maintain [:mad:]. Its not the 928 ppl tend to think of but for me its the only one I would have.
 
I always struggle with this question. Largely because I can't understand why so many people spend fortunes turning perfectly good road cars in to a bad compromise between road and track. Not wishing to upset anyone, just my honest opinion. [&:]

Having been driven round a track in a few very well developed track cars, Peter Empson's white car and a certain little Honda spring to mind, makes me realise just how good a dedicated track car is. Pretty much every car that's trying to be half track/half road car seems to cost it's owner far too much and then be good at neither.

My question would be what do you want out of a car, and what are you not getting from the 944 at the moment? If it's just a power thing, get a cheap 'Vette and have a laugh in a straight line. If it's a track toy then get something you can trailer there and not be compromised. Different cheap cars for different uses.

Personally I can't see how your particular 944 would be improved for regular road use by spending money on making it faster. It seemed to be keeping up with my S2 on the way to Frontrunners without any noticeable issues, and I can't see how we'd have been going any faster or having any more fun on the public roads without being stupid. Surely upping the power will only make you reach the responsible limits a tiny bit quicker, and be more frustrating?

So. We're agreed it's another car then. [:)]

More details please. Are you after a real classic, like an MG? A modern classic like a Quattro? Something mad like an old Aston? Possibly a V8 Aston, I like Astons. A Virage, perhaps? Proper old Vantage? [&:]
 
If I did get something else it would need to be something that offers something different from what my 944 does. So hence my leaning towards a GT or svelte saloon or indeed something that isn't quick at all but looks lovely. Or some car that brings back memories from my childhood. For instance (will probably get pilloried for this) but always wanted a Mark 1 Granada or a Vauxhall Magnum/Firenza or Rover P6 or P5B. Or from later era an SD1 or Lancia or various types. My problem with getting another car is

a) Would I ever get the chance to drive it or would it just nd up mouldering on my drive way ?

b) Its not just the purchase cost but the subsequent running and maintainance costs that need to be taken into account.

I know what you mean Paul about why get more power but then if I don't I will always get the niggling feeling that the 944 isn't quite as good as I could have made it (even if thats still some way short of an S2...)
 

ORIGINAL: sawood12

Voted for the Jag. I have a soft spot for Jags, but I suspect that getting more power in your 944 turbo will only temporarily satisfy your hunger for more, so there is logic in spending the money on something else to distract you from the boost addiction. I nice Jag to cruise around in will be jut the ticket I think - a nice relaxing drive instead.

I keep staring at this....

http://www.carandclassic.co.uk/car/C147542/
 
More power (having done several tens of thousand miles in a turbo with over 300BHP) allows for quicker overtaking which opens up many opportunities for doing so. In addition generally as I could no longer use all the performance as often the economy improved. Having said all that in the cab I don't often miss the extra horses, though occasionally it does feel a little sluggish. The Coupe has the ability to get the adrenalin flowing more often, and does require some respect on the loud the pedal.
Tony
 

ORIGINAL: Neil Haughey

If you can find one, S2 with a manual gearbox. At the time when I got our 968 there was a really fantastic looking condition one that had been up for sale for ages and I went and bought the 968 instead thinking it would be cheaper to maintain [:mad:]. Its not the 928 ppl tend to think of but for me its the only one I would have.

Yes a 928 S2 manual really appeals but the only one I have found recently is rather more than my budget permits,
 
f I did get something else it would need to be something that offers something different from what my 944 does. So hence my leaning towards a GT or svelte saloon or indeed something that isn't quick at all but looks lovely. Or some car that brings back memories from my childhood. For instance (will probably get pilloried for this) but always wanted a Mark 1 Granada or a Vauxhall Magnum/Firenza or Rover P6 or P5B. Or from later era an SD1 or Lancia or various types.

Every one a real classic. I still miss most of my early cars, MK2 Escorts, great Mk5 Cortina, Vivas, even the Allegro. To me the point of a "retro" car is a mix of desireability over cost, and I'm very limited on costs. Hence the 944 is cheaper to run than a rusty old Ford and has a lot more presence. Would love a classic "Sweeny" Granada, or an early Capri. That Jag is stunning, but I'd always go for an XJS myself. Breaking the piggy bank open as I type......[&:]
 
ORIGINAL: Suffolk944

If I did get something else it would need to be something that offers something different from what my 944 does. So hence my leaning towards a GT or svelte saloon or indeed something that isn't quick at all but looks lovely. Or some car that brings back memories from my childhood. For instance (will probably get pilloried for this) but always wanted a Mark 1 Granada or a Vauxhall Magnum/Firenza

How about a Granada Coupe??? Saw one today on the back of a transporter.... looked like it was mid restoration and had just been resprayed.

Or how about a Droopsnot Firenza or a Sporthatch? Nice and rare... Had a mate who was crazy about Firenzas and Magnums... Worked at Vauxhall Ellesmere Port and had a very nice Droopsnoot, before getting into Opel Mantas.

 
Get yerself a Hillman Imp! Puts hairs on yer chest and gives you the true 911 experience with non of the snobbery![:D]
 

ORIGINAL: Frenchy

Got me a 735i V8 Cosmos Black sand beige leather with 12 way electric sport seats, lovely condition................pure joy.
Cost a fortune new and i got it for less than the price of a fancy telly.

I've got a 735i too, albeit the straight six E32. Amazing amount of car for the money right now [:D]
 
Hmm though surely if its 1980 it will be an S rather than S2...

http://www.pistonheads.com/sales/2212300.htm
 
ORIGINAL: Diver944
Maybe a good S2?

ORIGINAL: pauljmcnulty
It seemed to be keeping up with my S2 on the way to Frontrunners without any noticeable issues ...

Paul & Paul. Beers on me next time we meet up. Speaking the truth should always be rewarded ... [:)]

(My answer? 20v UR-Quattro, if you can afford a good one. Although I should be sensible and ask what other car you have at the moment apart from your 951, and what you are looking to do with whatever it is you buy?)


Oli.
 
You see I went for a classic range rover when I was in your position. In the right budget range for you and definitely meets the different circumstances brief.
No problems about wet, snowy winters when lesser (or less appropriate) vehicles are struggling and I'm less concerned about a few scratches here and there.
Just a thought.
 
Old cars always seem very appealing but, perhaps, we have been spoilt with our association with 944's. All old cars rust. I had a Mk 1 Capri 20 years ago and it was probably more rusty then than my 944 is now. Old cars are like old girlfriends, best remembered for the good times and never revisited.

Modern cars are so good in comparison, and so cheap second hand, why would you do anything but get a good 2nd hand modern car?

Bigger turbo? No, no, no, no, no and no. Turbo's are a pain in the bum and far less fun to drive than the nice linear power delivery of something that doesn't have a turbo. OK you do get that big grin from the booooooooooost but, unless you like waiting for the car to settle after a bend before planting the loud pedal (which also isn't as loud as it could be because of the Turbo) why bother? And a bigger turbo just means you have to wait longer.

All that Paul has said above is true. Some of what Tony has said is true as well but I come back to my modern car bit again. Last year (?) we had a right grin on the way to Cornbury when Paul and others tried to keep up with my 3.0 ltr X Type - they didn't. I was relaxed and comfy and secure in the knowledge I had enough airbags to re-float a small battle ship, modern ABS, 4WD, crumple zones, fault diagnostics, proper lights 230bhp, and all the other things that are standard on even the most mundane cars. Really nice car which I got £3.5K for when I sold it......There wasn't even a hint of rust on the entire car. It is almost criminal that a car that good is so cheap - so why not take advantage of something like that?
 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top