Menu toggle

S2 For Sale?

zcacogp

New member
Chaps,

Apologies for the provocative title but that wet turd of a mayor Sadiq Khan has today confirmed that he will extend the ULEZ to Greater London from 25th October 2021. (The irony of him ensuring that Londoners have air that's cleaner than that which swirls around the Swiss Alps while doing precisely nothing about the spate of moped muggings is has not been missed, trust me.) That means that in three years time it will cost me £12.50p to drive to the end of my road, go to the shops, drive to church on Sunday etc etc etc. More details here, but make sure you are sitting down when you read them:

https://www.london.gov.uk...n-zone-to-expand

Which raises the question of what I should do? Situation: married couple in their early 40's, no kids, extensive use of bicycles and Oyster Cards during the week, the car is used for shopping, trips when we have more than we can carry on our persons and trips out of town at the weekend. It currently does around 6000 miles a year. (A significant factor that will affect this is elderly parents needing more time, none of whom live close. Thankfully that hasn't happened yet but doubtless it will). Two seats is viable, although a decent carrying capacity from time to time is very useful. We live in Central London, outside the congestion charge zone but well within the new ULEZ area.

First question is what do I do with the current car? 1989 S2, excellent condition, meticulously maintained, I have every receipt/tax disk/MOT since new and can tell you everything that has been done to it since I purchased it in 2006. Mechanically perfect, excellent bodywork (few scratches and minor scuffs but nothing serious), original sills. Downside is immense mileage - I think it's about 208,000, which will knock the value. It's a car I bought to drive, and it's been enjoyed but very well looked after. One serious option is to keep it and simply swallow the £12 each time I drive it. However another option would be to lay it up; I have enough access to dry inside space to keep it in and our long-term future doesn't lie in London so I would do this with a view to getting it out again in the next 10 years or so. However it's probably more likely that I will sell the thing for whatever I can get and put the cash into something else.

Second question is that if I either replace the current car or lay it up, what do I buy to replace it? Criteria are that it needs to be excellent to drive, have a half-decent carrying capability, not be stupidly expensive to own and run (taking into account fuel efficiency, insurance, tax, depreciation etc etc etc). Budget is very flexible; getting the right car is more important than money. I probably wouldn't want to go for something much slower than the current car but I'm not too fussed on this. I'll admit to being quite bitten by the Porsche bug so the obvious choice is a Boxster but Mrs zcacogp doesn't like them. A 987 or 981 Cayman would be a more acceptable option. A 993 would be my ultimate dream car but would fall foul of the new ULEZ so wouldn't solve the presenting problem. A more modern 911 would be an option but they've never quite appealed. Cars more than 40 years old qualify for free road tax, no congestion charge and don't need to pay the ULEZ so a really old 911 would maybe be an option but they seem to be terribly expensive these days (and may prove to be a maintenance nightmare - they don't seem to be cheap to run).

An MX5 would be a serious option but I'm not sure it's practical (or maybe fast) enough. Mrs zcacogp is seriously thinking about a Quattroporte but I think that would be a VERY expensive thing and I don't know anyone who has one who can say that they really love it. A Bristol would be a leftfield choice but I don't feel old enough to own one yet.

Fast BMW? No thanks. Fast Merc? Definitely no thanks. Fast Audi? Not a chance.

Retreat to the safety of a Golf GTi? Maybe, but I fear it would be horribly dull after a 944.

The only other option would be to stick it to that idiot Khan and buy an electric car, charge it for free, not pay any road tax/congestion charge/ULEZ bollox and park it anywhere. Range is the issue, as well as the fact that electric cars are still in their infancy and things like the i3 don't really do it for me - that would be a choice made with my head, not heart. However I suspect that electric car tech will move on a lot in the next few years so this could be an option yet.

What's the point of this thread? There isn't one. Well, I guess there is. The writing is on the wall that older cars will become harder and harder to own, particularly in big cities in the UK. I am realising that I won't be able to drive my beloved S2 in my home town for much longer. And I'd value any suggestions (both sensible and nuts) for what to do next. There is no rush; I have three years before the ULEZ comes into force but I will need to do something, and I simply don't know what.

So, emote with me chaps*. And give me some wisdom. Ta.

Oli.

* - I can't believe that I actually wrote that phrase on here. And so soon after Tom talked about 'birthing' too. This place gets more and more like Mumsnet every day ... :)
 
Oli

I can only offer sympathy for you, but fully understand your situation

the big issue with this ULEZ is that it’s just another tax, it will do very little for air quality,

the 968 sales blurb said the air coming out the exhaust is cleaner than what went in the air intake, looking at my mot figures, that’s almost believable.

the Big problem is the huge amount of 10-15 year old badly maintained diesel cars vans trucks buses and more than anything dam black smoking taxis

not sure what your answer is but a bullet through mr khan’s head might not be a bad place to start and then work our way through the rest of the stupid self serving politicians

 
The obvious answer is to plan to move away from London to a more 944 friendly place before house prices drop as more & more people do the same & our house prices rocket as a result!

 
Nice thought Vitesse but its not gonna happen,,,,Prices in inner London and Greater London will continue to rocket and even more so when crossrail opens,,,,,,,



 
Martin, you are spot on in everything you say - I can't agree more. It's a money-raising measure and a VERY blunt instrument to tackle the problem which isn't caused by cars like ours.

If I saw Khan crossing the road in front of me while out driving then I'd simply claim that my brakes failed. (Either that or say that the throttle jammed open and the mighty power of an S2 was too much for me to handle! [:)])

Colin, that's not a daft suggestion; we won't be in London for evermore. But we are likely to be here beyond 2021 so an answer will have to be found.

Jason - will prices continue to rise en Londres? It would be nice to think so but the price of your house only matters on two days in your life; the day you buy it and the day you sell it. Anything in between is boasting or speculation, nothing more.

Oli.

 
I wish the prices would drop,,,,

its got crazy and makes moving on very hard unless your going outside of the m25,,,,,,,

I would move out of NE London tommorow alas my wife dont feel the same,,,,,,jasonp

 
Tough one Oli. If I was in your position I think I would probably suck it and see. If you’ve got the budget to change cars then you’ve probably got the budget to pay the ULEZ tax so it then just boils down to principles and a grudge match between you and the esteemed mayor.

Or just move out to the sticks and pay 5 grand a year to commute back in again. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t.

 
Well I sympathise with your predicament Oli, but can see why it's proposed. (Btw I believe Khan is acting on moped gangs but maybe not a subject for this thread..)

The obvious answer is to move away from that hellhole of a city to somewhere with decent roads [;)]

A Cayman 2.7 would be an obvious choice. Coupled with a carnewal exhaust... It's much safer than a 3.4 and should have similar performance to the mighty S2 while sounding a whole lot better.

A 996 might be too old otherwise that would be a great choice. It still has that analogue feel & proper control weights.

I know the euro4 standard was roughly 2005 onwards - I don't suppose there's a slim chance that Porsche were ahead of the game and produced lovely low emissions much earlier than that?

 
Stage 1

Buy or rent warehouses just outside the ULEZ, offer car parking services for older cherised vehicles (with electric charging) for those who live in the zone.

Stage 2

Use profits form above to buy an electric vehicle for buzzing round town i8? park it in your warehouse (on charge) and take the porsche for a drive, whilst allowing others to do the same.

Stage 3

Retire to somewhere better ;)

 
Cumbria is epic and no bullshit charges (taxes) move !

seriously though, buy a cheapie that will get you around town keep the S2 which you obviously love for special trips, it will make you appreciate it more.

Thank F I live in England and not down there.

 
Tom, you're right in that the cost to change car would be not dissimilar to the cost of keeping the current car and paying the ULEZ charge. However paying such a thing would stick in the craw just too much for me to stomach. Buying a new car would expose me to depreciation but I guess I'm just lucky that I haven't had to pay that with my current 944.

I don't agree that having money means I should pay (although I appreciate that you aren't suggesting this); motorists in London already pay some way over the odds compared to elsewhere and sucking up another government charge "just because I'm a Londoner" is offensive. I currently pay more for my parking permit to park on my own road than I do in road tax. Yes, I pay more to park than I do to drive, and that's before you count in the congestion charge (which I try to avoid) and pesky things like bus lane fines, which are far more prevalent in Central London than elsewhere. And all this on top of the regular nationwide treatment of motorists being wallets on wheels.

Ed, a 2.7 Cayman is indeed the obvious choice. And a very nice car as well. Will it see 200,000 miles, as my 944 has? I doubt it. But that's another question for another forum.

Tony, interesting plan. I'll give it some thought, thanks. Sounds very like Classic Remise in Berlin - which Ed introduced me to and which is excellent!

(An aside but I am more disappointed by PCGB's lack of noise on this matter. The proposed charge has been in the press for the last 9 month or so and PCGB likes to promote Porsche as supporting owners of older models but I'm not aware that they have said a thing about this charge. I eMailed the club office about it several months ago and have heard nothing back from them. Where was that thread that talked about all the benefits of being a PCGB member as I think I may have something to add to it.)

Oli.

 
Frenchy said:
Cumbria is epic and no bull**** charges (taxes) move !

Moving the the family farm up there is something I will do in the next few years and I agree - it is a beautiful, beautiful place. However this is likely to happen after the ULEZ is introduced in London, hence this thread.

 
I believe that all historic cars are exempt from this charge, current date being those built before 1980....IIRC this date rolls on each year as cars get older...the way I see it with stronger and stronger admission charges being ruled on is that we may get to the stage were the only vehicles allowed in the ultra n zone are electric or historic vehicles...to me that means keeping a classic (soon to be historic car) which may be the only way of enjoying driving in London without being charged/taxed. Current cars that will be charged are those built between Jan 1980 to Jan 2006....there are an awful lot of dirty engines built after 2006...therefore I can see this date changing as the rules get tougher, even to include brand new cars coming off the production line today.. Keeping today's classic cars ready to use once historic and thus exempt seems the best choice for a car enthusiast....today it's the cities...mark my words this will spread...far and wide as we get closer to the total ban of the internal combustion engine 2040 with some MP's pushing for 2030...total exception for historic's is the future that I see....something to ponder on guys, that's for sure...

Pete

 

Posts made and opinions expressed are those of the individual forum members

Use of the Forum is subject to the Terms and Conditions

Disclaimer

The opinions expressed on this site are not necessarily those of the Club, who shall have no liability in respect of them or the accuracy of the content. The Club assumes no responsibility for any effects arising from errors or omissions.

Porsche Club Great Britain gives no warranties, guarantees or assurances and makes no representations or recommendations regarding any goods or services advertised on this site. It is the responsibility of visitors to satisfy themselves that goods and/or services supplied by any advertiser are bona fide and in no instance can the Porsche Club Great Britain be held responsible.

When responding to advertisements please ensure that you satisfy yourself of any applicable call charges on numbers not prefixed by usual "landline" STD Codes. Information can be obtained from the operator or the white pages. Before giving out ANY information regarding cars, or any other items for sale, please satisfy yourself that any potential purchaser is bona fide.

Directors of the Board of Porsche Club GB, Club Office Staff, Register Secretaries and Regional Organisers are often requested by Club members to provide information on matters connected with their cars and other matters referred to in the Club Rules. Such information, advice and assistance provided by such persons is given in good faith and is based on the personal experience and knowledge of the individual concerned.

Neither Porsche Club GB, nor any of the aforementioned, shall be under any liability in respect of any such information, advice or assistance given to members. Members are advised to consult qualified specialists for information, advice and assistance on matters connected with their cars at all times.

Back
Top